Searching for domestic round-trip airfare is kind of like using MapQuest printouts — it still works, but it’s not how most people actually travel anymore.
Most U.S. airlines price tickets by the segment. So a “round trip” is usually just two one-way flights bundled under a single confirmation number. Which means you can (and should) price each direction separately and build the itinerary that actually fits your schedule.
That part is easy.
The cheap flight mistake points people still make happens right after that: they optimize for the lowest number on the search screen (or the best cents-per-point), and accidentally downgrade what they’re buying.
Because the “cheapest” option is often cheaper for a reason:
- It’s a different fare type (hello, Basic Economy)
- It’s on a different booking channel (portal vs. booking direct)
- It’s built out of separate pieces that don’t protect you when something goes wrong
And here’s the twist that matters for points people: award tickets are often more flexible than cash tickets. If you cancel within the rules, you’ll frequently get your points back. If you paid cash, you may only end up with a flight credit — not your money back — depending on the fare and airline.
So the goal isn’t just “find the cheapest flight.” It’s to build the cheapest trip you’d still be comfortable dealing with on a bad travel day.
The good news is you can avoid most of this with a simple process: get a baseline, price each direction, then sanity-check what you’re actually buying.
Step 1: Run a Round-Trip Search (Baseline Only)
Start with a round-trip search once. Not because you’re committing to it — but because it shows you:
- Which airlines fly the route
- What normal pricing looks like for your dates
- Whether the “best deal” is hiding a catch (fare type, bags, timing)
Step 2: Price Each Direction as a One-Way
Now search your outbound as a one-way, then your return as a one-way. This is where you’ll often find a better combo:
- Airline A has the best outbound schedule/price
- Airline B has the best return schedule/price
Just keep one rule front and center: compare the same product.
If one option is Basic Economy and the other is Main Cabin, you’re not comparing fares — you’re comparing two different sets of rules.
The 3 Traps That Create “Cheap Flight Regret”
1) The Fare-Type Trap
A cheap fare is sometimes only cheap until you add what you actually need:
- a carry-on or checked bag
- a seat assignment
- reasonable change/cancel rules
- boarding earlier than the last group
If you’re a points person comparing “points vs. cash,” this matters because an award ticket often behaves like a more flexible fare. If your cash comparison is the cheapest, most restrictive fare, the math can be misleading.
2) The “Separate Pieces” Trap (Positioning Flights Can Bite You)
Mixing airlines is fine. Booking separate tickets can be fine too. The problem is when you build a trip out of pieces that don’t protect each other — especially when one of those pieces is a positioning flight to catch a long-haul departure.
If you’re flying from your home airport to another city just to start an international itinerary, the “cheap” move is often to book a separate domestic ticket to position yourself for the long-haul flight. And sometimes that works perfectly.
But if your positioning flight is delayed or canceled and you miss the long-haul flight that’s on a totally separate ticket, you may be on your own. The long-haul airline isn’t obligated to treat that as a protected connection, and the rebooking costs can turn your “cheap” plan into the most expensive flight decision you make all year.
This is one of those situations where it can be worth paying extra to stay within the same airline (or at least within the same alliance), or booking it as a single ticket whenever possible. You’re not just paying for a seat — you’re paying for the itinerary to be treated as one trip when things go sideways.
If you do decide to book positioning flights separately, the best defense is to build in time: arrive the night before, choose earlier flights, and don’t cut it close just because the schedule looks good on paper.
3) The Portal Trap (When “Pay With Points” Adds Friction)
Portals can be useful. Sometimes they’re even the simplest way to use points like cash at checkout.
But here’s the catch: when you book through a portal or online travel agency, you’ve added a middleman. And when you need help — a schedule change, a cancellation, a same-day adjustment, or a refund — that extra layer can turn a quick fix into a “who owns this ticket?” situation.
This is where points people get burned: the portal deal looks great right up until you need a human to fix something.
If it’s a straightforward domestic trip and you’re price-shopping, a portal booking might be perfectly fine. If it’s an important trip, a tight itinerary, or anything involving positioning to a long-haul flight, I’d rather book in the way that gives me the fewest extra steps when something goes wrong.
The 60-Second Checklist Before You Book
Before you hit purchase, run through this quick list:
- Am I comparing the same fare type? (Basic Economy vs. Main Cabin is not the same product.)
- What’s the real total cost? Bags, seats, and any fees that erase the “savings.”
- Is this one ticket or separate tickets? If it’s separate, who protects me if Flight #1 goes bad?
- Am I positioning for a long-haul flight? If yes, is it worth paying more to keep it protected (same ticket/airline/alliance) or building in a buffer?
- Who will I have to deal with if I need help? Airline directly, or a portal/OTA?
- Would points be more flexible here? On many U.S. carriers, canceling an award often returns points (within the rules), while a cash ticket may leave you with credit instead of money back.
Final Thoughts
Pricing flights one-way is smart. Mixing airlines can be smart. Using points can be smart.
The mistake happens when you treat “cheapest” as the finish line.
The best deal is the one that still works when your day doesn’t. If a slightly higher fare keeps your itinerary protected, reduces the chance you’ll be stuck buying a last-minute replacement ticket, or makes cancellations and changes easier, that’s not overspending — that’s buying resilience. Because “cheap” isn’t the goal — a trip that holds together is.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
