Airline award pricing is supposed to follow some kind of logic, right? You search for a flight, pick your dates, and expect to see economy priced lower than first class. But thanks to a mix of dynamic pricing, limited partner availability, and wildly different award charts, things don’t always add up. Case in point: I recently booked a first class seat for fewer miles than economy—and it wasn’t even close.
Here’s what happened.
American vs. Alaska: Same Flight, Very Different Prices
I was looking at a nonstop flight operated by American Airlines. If I booked through American’s AAdvantage program, they wanted 19,500 miles + $5.60 for an economy seat and 35,500 miles + $5.60 for first class.
Then I checked Alaska Airlines, which partners with American. Alaska was offering the same first-class seat for just 15,000 Mileage Plan miles + $12.50.
Not only is that nearly 60% fewer miles than booking with American, but it was also cheaper than American’s own economy pricing. And because American wasn’t opening economy award seats to partners, Alaska didn’t even show an option to book coach.
Why Alaska’s Miles Went Further
Alaska still uses a region-based partner award chart, which makes pricing more predictable, at least for now.
For flights within the Americas, “Business Class” awards (which is how Alaska categorizes domestic first class on American) start at:
- 9,000 miles for flights under 700 miles
- 15,000 miles for flights between 701–1,400 miles
Since my flight was in that 701–1,400 mile range, it was priced at 15K—as expected. Compare that to American’s 35.5K for the exact same seat and the value becomes crystal clear.
AA Likely Released Space—Because the Cabin Was Empty
So why was this seat even available to Alaska Mileage Plan members? The most likely reason: American released partner award space because the first class cabin wasn’t selling.
I pulled up the seat map, and sure enough, most of the first class cabin was still empty.
When load factors are low, airlines sometimes open up award space to partners.
The Value Breakdown
The cash price for the same seat was about $650. Using just 15,000 Alaska miles plus the $12.50 nonrefundable partner booking fee, I got more than 4 cents per mile in value. That’s a great use of Mileage Plan miles by any standard.
Why Alaska Mileage Plan Is Still a Fan Favorite
Getting a first class seat for fewer miles than economy is a great deal—but it’s not just a one-off fluke. Alaska Mileage Plan has built a reputation for delivering solid value, and this redemption is a prime example of why the program remains so well-liked.
Both American and Alaska are members of oneworld (yes, that’s intentionally lowercase with three bold letters—there’s a story behind that), but Alaska goes a step further by partnering with several non-alliance airlines, such as Singapore Airlines. That wider partner network gives members more booking options than most loyalty programs.
Even after switching to a unified partner award chart, there are still pockets of strong value—especially for flights within the Americas and certain international redemptions. Alaska’s transparent pricing, combined with a healthy variety of partners, makes it one of the few U.S. programs that still rewards thoughtful booking strategies.
Final Thoughts
I usually wouldn’t be looking to book a first-class ticket for a flight like this. It’s a short hop, and economy would’ve been just fine. But when first class costs less than economy? I couldn’t pass it up.
This was a great reminder that award travel isn’t always logical, but that can work in your favor if you know where to look. Thanks to Alaska’s predictable pricing and access to partner inventory, I was able to score a premium seat for fewer miles than the one in the back.
The key? Always check partner programs—especially those that still use award charts. Dynamic pricing may be the new normal, but programs like Alaska Mileage Plan prove there’s still value to be found if you’re willing to do a little digging.
It’s not just about getting a better seat. It’s about making your miles go further and enjoying the ride while you’re at it.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
