Hyatt has always had a different kind of loyalty following. It’s smaller than Marriott or Hilton, the elite program has historically felt more meaningful, and many longtime guests stuck with Hyatt because the experience felt more consistent — especially at “classic” full-service brands like Hyatt Regency and Grand Hyatt.
But Hyatt’s strategy over the past few years has been clear: grow faster by expanding into categories that attract higher-spending travelers — all-inclusive resorts, wellness retreats like Miraval, and a growing lineup of lifestyle / boutique properties (including Unbound Collection hotels and other soft brands).
That’s not automatically a bad thing. More options mean more places to earn and burn points. But it also raises a question I keep coming back to:
Is Hyatt losing touch with the guests who got them here — in order to win over a newer, wealthier, experience-driven customer who may not be as loyal in the first place?
When the perks get “soft,” loyalty starts to feel less certain
One consistent theme I hear from longtime Hyatt loyalists is that elite benefits feel less predictable than they used to. Not just because hotels are cutting corners — but because the portfolio is now so much broader.
At a classic full-service Hyatt, Globalist benefits are easy to understand: upgrades, late checkout, lounge access (when available), free breakfast, and the general sense that you’re being taken care of.
But at newer categories — especially all-inclusives and wellness properties — those “standard” benefits can get blurry. If every guest already has meals included, what does free breakfast even mean? If a resort’s experience is built around packages, credits, and on-property programming, the traditional elite checklist doesn’t always translate cleanly.
In theory, Hyatt can still “recognize” elites at these properties. In practice, many loyalists describe it as inconsistent: sometimes you feel valued, sometimes you feel like you’re just… there.
My own moment of “what’s actually valuable?” at Great Scotland Yard
This is where my own experience really clicked.
When I stayed at Great Scotland Yard (an Unbound Collection property), I had a choice. I could use a Guest of Honor and lean into the “soft” perks — the kind of benefits that make Hyatt status feel special, like breakfast and on-property recognition.
Or I could use a Suite Upgrade Award and lock in something tangible: a bigger room.
I chose the suite.
Not because I don’t value breakfast — but because in that moment, breakfast felt negotiable, while space felt guaranteed. In a city hotel where room size can make or break the stay, I cared more about the hard benefit than the soft one.
And that made me wonder: if even loyalists are starting to prioritize guaranteed room outcomes over elite perks like breakfast, what does that say about Hyatt’s direction?
The Regency Club lounge problem isn’t just about food
Another issue that keeps coming up — and it’s one I think matters more than Hyatt wants to admit — is the slow, uneven return of club lounges at Hyatt Regency and Grand Hyatt properties.
Yes, some lounges have reopened. But many have stayed closed for years, or reopened in a diminished form. And even when hotels provide a “replacement,” it often feels like a workaround rather than a real amenity.
This isn’t just about snacks and coffee. It’s about what a lounge represents: a visible signal that a hotel is investing in the experience of its most loyal guests.
If Hyatt is positioning itself as more premium — as more luxury-adjacent — then the on-property experience needs to support that story. A strong brand narrative can only do so much when loyal guests show up expecting a core benefit, only to be told it no longer exists.
Is Hyatt becoming harder to trust — even if it’s growing?
One of Hyatt’s historical advantages was that it felt more cohesive. Fewer brands. Clearer expectations. Less guesswork about what a stay would look like.
Now, the portfolio spans everything from wellness retreats to all-inclusive mega-resorts to design-forward boutiques. That breadth might attract new customers — especially travelers who prioritize experiences over brand loyalty — but it also makes Hyatt feel less uniform.
And that uncertainty may be becoming even more important. At the same time Hyatt is expanding into all these new segments, there have also been rumors — and at this point they are only rumors — about possible changes to Globalist, including the idea of adding an even higher elite tier above it.
If that happens, it could make some longtime loyalists wonder whether Hyatt is not only changing what its hotels look like, but also changing who its loyalty program is really built for. Is the goal still to reward the guests who made Hyatt stand out, or to create a new top rung for a different kind of customer?
The question
Hyatt’s expansion may be a smart business move. It may be exactly where the money is. And it may be the right play to compete for premium travelers who care more about a property’s vibe than the logo on the keycard.
But here’s what I keep coming back to. Are those “new wealthy” travelers actually loyal?
Or are they simply customers — happy to book the next great experience wherever it lives, whether that’s Hyatt today or someone else tomorrow?
Because if Hyatt starts weakening the experience at the legacy brands — and if the benefits for loyalists become more inconsistent across the portfolio — then Hyatt risks losing something it can’t easily buy back, the trust of the guests who helped build the program’s reputation in the first place.
What do you think? Is Hyatt’s growth making the program stronger, or is it slowly trading loyalty for lifestyle?
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
