Booking directly with a hotel is usually the cleanest option. You earn hotel points, elite credit, credit card rewards and whatever benefits come with your status.
But every once in a while, the math changes.
That happened on our recent trip to Texas, where I booked a four-night stay at a Homewood Suites through the Bilt travel portal instead of booking directly with Hilton.
Normally, that would make me pause. Booking through a portal usually means giving up Hilton Honors points, elite night credit and whatever elite benefits would apply. But in this case, Bilt gave me enough stacked value that the portal booking made more sense.
The Bilt Portal Booking
The stay came to $803 total.
Here’s how that broke down:
- Rooms & services: $710.60
- Taxes: $81.84
- Fees: $10.56
- Total: $803.00
Since I booked through the Bilt travel portal, I was able to apply my $200 Bilt travel credit. I also used $100 in Bilt Cash, which is available monthly depending on your Bilt setup and status level.
That brought the amount billed to my card down to $503.
Because I paid with my Bilt Palladium card and used Bilt Cash to boost my earning rate, I earned 3X Bilt points on the remaining balance.
That works out to:
- $503 x 3 = 1,509 Bilt points
For this comparison, I’m valuing Bilt points at 1.8 cents each. That’s not the highest valuation you’ll see, but it’s a reasonable middle ground between more conservative and more aggressive estimates.
That makes the points earned worth about:
- 1,509 Bilt points x 1.8 cents = $27.16
So the Bilt side of the equation looked like this:
- $200 Bilt travel credit
- $100 Bilt Cash redeemed
- About $27 in Bilt points earned
Total value against the stay: about $327.
What If I Had Booked Directly With Hilton?
This is where things get interesting.
If I had booked directly with Hilton, I would have earned Hilton Honors points, a Gold elite bonus, points from paying with my Hilton Honors American Express Surpass Card and points from Hilton’s current promotion.
But this was a Homewood Suites.
That matters.
Hilton Honors members earn 10 base points per dollar at many Hilton brands. However, Homewood Suites is one of the brands that earns only 5 base points per dollar on eligible spend. Hilton’s terms specifically list Homewood Suites among the brands that earn 5 base points per dollar instead of 10. Hilton Gold members then receive an 80% bonus on those base points. Hilton’s terms also say taxes are not considered eligible spend for points accrual.
That makes the direct-booking math less impressive than it would be at a full-service Hilton brand.
Using the $710.60 room-and-services amount as the eligible Hilton spend:
- Base Hilton points: $710.60 x 5 = 3,553 points
- Gold 80% bonus: 2,842 points
- Hilton Surpass Card: $803 x 12 = 9,636 points
- Four-night Hilton promo bonus: 4,000 points
That comes to about:
- 20,031 Hilton Honors points
For this comparison, I’m valuing Hilton points at 0.5 cents each. That’s a rounded average between Frequent Miler’s more conservative Hilton valuation and AwardWallet’s higher real-world redemption data.
At 0.5 cents each, those 20,031 Hilton points would be worth about:
- 20,031 x 0.5 cents = $100.16
The Direct Booking Still Had Some Value
Booking directly with Hilton would not have been worthless.
I would have earned around $100 in Hilton points value. I also would have earned elite night credit and stay credit, which can matter if you’re working toward Hilton status.
But that wasn’t a major consideration for this stay.
I already had Hilton Gold status from the Surpass Card, and this was a Homewood Suites. We weren’t giving up a meaningful suite upgrade, lounge access or a big breakfast benefit by booking elsewhere. Homewood Suites already includes breakfast, and the brand is more about practical extended-stay lodging than elite-status pampering.
That makes it much easier to justify booking through a portal.
If this had been a Conrad, Waldorf Astoria, Curio Collection or another Hilton brand where elite benefits could be more meaningful, I’d be more cautious. At a Homewood Suites, the tradeoff was easier.
The Side-By-Side Math
Assuming the price was exactly the same through Bilt and Hilton, here’s the comparison:
| Booking Method | Estimated Value Earned / Saved |
|---|---|
| Bilt portal with $200 credit, $100 Bilt Cash and 3X points | About $327 |
| Hilton direct with Gold, Surpass Card and four-night promo | About $100 |
That gives the Bilt portal booking an advantage of about $227.
The Homewood Suites Factor
The biggest lesson here is that the Hilton-direct calculation depends heavily on the brand.
If this had been a Hilton brand earning 10 base points per dollar, the direct-booking side would have looked better. But Homewood Suites only earns 5 base points per dollar on eligible spend.
That cuts the base points in half before the elite bonus is even applied.
For a casual Hilton stay where I don’t need elite credit, don’t expect much from elite benefits and have a strong portal credit to use, that makes booking elsewhere much easier to justify.
Final Thought
I still prefer booking directly with hotels in many situations. It’s cleaner, safer and usually better if you care about elite credit, status benefits or dealing directly with the hotel if something goes wrong.
But not every stay needs to be treated the same way.
For this Homewood Suites stay, the direct-booking upside was limited. The brand only earns 5 Hilton points per dollar, the elite benefits weren’t especially meaningful, and the value of the Hilton points I would have earned was nowhere close to the combination of the Bilt travel credit, Bilt Cash and Bilt points.
So while booking direct with Hilton would have earned more hotel-program credit, the Bilt portal was the better deal for this particular stay.
And that’s the point. Booking direct is usually the default. But when portal credits are large enough, and the hotel stay doesn’t offer much elite upside, the math can flip pretty quickly.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
