I usually start an award search with the airline operating the flight. But this booking was a good reminder to check its partners before redeeming miles.
I needed a nonstop flight from Dallas-Fort Worth to Orlando, and economy would have been perfectly fine for the trip. But when I checked the award pricing through American AAdvantage, the numbers weren’t especially appealing.
American wanted 19,500 miles plus $5.60 for an economy seat. First class was available for 35,500 miles plus $5.60.
I’ve paid more for flights, but I still wanted to make sure that was the best option. So I checked whether Alaska Airlines Mileage Plan could be used for the same flight.
It could, but only in first class. As it turned out, that wasn’t a bad thing at all.
In other words, American wanted 4,500 more miles for an economy seat than Alaska wanted for the exact same flight in first class.
I wasn’t going to spend more miles to sit in the back.
Same Flight, Three Very Different Prices
Here was the comparison:
- American AAdvantage economy: 19,500 miles plus $5.60
- American AAdvantage first class: 35,500 miles plus $5.60
- Alaska Mileage Plan first class: 15,000 miles plus $12.50
Here’s what Alaska was asking for the same flight.
That’s the type of award pricing that makes no sense until you remember that each loyalty program controls its own prices.
Why Alaska Charged Fewer Miles
American dynamically prices awards booked through AAdvantage. The number of miles required can change depending on demand, the flight and whatever other factors American uses to set the price.
Alaska priced the flight according to its distance-based partner award chart.
For flights within the Americas, Alaska prices partner business class—which includes domestic first class on American—based on distance. Flights between 701 and 1,400 miles start at 15,000 miles each way.
Since Dallas-Fort Worth to Orlando falls within that distance band, the award is priced at 15,000 Alaska miles.
American wasn’t offering economy award space to Alaska, so coach didn’t appear as an option through Mileage Plan. That created the unusual situation where Alaska could book first class but not economy.
The Operating Airline Isn’t Always The Cheapest
I naturally started with American because it was operating the flight. But each loyalty program sets its own award prices, so the same seat can cost very different amounts depending on where you book it.
That doesn’t mean a partner will always be cheaper. Availability, fees and cancellation rules can all differ.
Still, this was a good reminder to check partner programs before redeeming miles—especially before transferring flexible points.
Was First Class Worth It?
For 15,000 Alaska miles, absolutely.
You can read our full review of the American Airlines A321 first-class flight here.
The wider seat and extra legroom made the flight more comfortable, and we received pre-departure drinks and a meal. It was a noticeable improvement over sitting in economy for the flight home.
But this was still domestic first class, not an aspirational international premium cabin.
There was no seatback entertainment, the meal was fine rather than memorable, and the priority tag on our checked bag didn’t help it arrive any faster.
American was later selling first class on the route for about $735. I wouldn’t have paid anything close to that amount.
But that wasn’t the choice I faced. My choice was between spending 19,500 American miles for economy or 15,000 Alaska miles for first class.
That was easy.
Check The Fine Print Before Booking
A partner award may require fewer miles, but it can come with different fees and rules for changes or cancellations.
In this case, Alaska charged a $12.50 nonrefundable partner booking fee, compared with $5.60 in taxes through American. Paying an extra $6.90 was an easy trade for saving 4,500 miles and moving from economy to first class.
On another booking, the difference may not be as clear.
Final Thoughts
I’m glad I checked Alaska before booking. I would have been perfectly fine flying economy, but there was no reason to spend more miles for it when first class was available for less.
I won’t assume Alaska will always have the better price, but this was a good reminder not to stop after checking the airline operating the flight. Sometimes a partner will price the exact same seat very differently.
In this case, a quick second search turned 19,500 miles in economy into 15,000 miles in first class.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
