It’s probably one of the most frustrating things about flying.
Your carry-on bag fits in the sizer, easy peasy lemon squeezy. But your boarding group number is pretty high….7, 8, 9…depending on what airline you’re on. And then you hear the dreaded words from the gate agent:
“There’s no more space in the overhead. You need to gate check your bag.”
For most airlines, you at least get to gate check it for free, instead of having to pay for a checked bag. But when an airline has lost your checked bag in the past (been there, done that), you might not really want to give up your bag that has 48-72 hours’ worth of clothes, y’know?
But the really frustrating part of it is that you get on the plane, and there is still plenty – and I mean PLENTY – of overhead space available.
So then why did the gate agent tell you there was no more space?
A couple of reasons:
History
Most airlines fly those routes daily. Sometimes a few times per day. And after years of doing this, they know that by the time you get to, I dunno, Group 8, there’s typically no more overhead space.
So first they start asking people to voluntarily check their carry-on bag. Then they warn you that Groups 8 and higher will have to gate check their bags. And as soon as they get to Group 8, the gate agent starts forcing passengers to start gate checking their carry-ons because historically, the overheads are usually filled by then.
And then you, in Boarding Group 8, get on board and there’s all this empty space because of reasons (plane’s not full, less people with carry on bags, more people proactively checked their carry-ons when they were given the opportunity, yadda yadda yadda).
Time
This one probably happens more than you think.
When a plane full of people are trying to figure out where to put their bags in the overheads and it turns into a big ol’ game of Tetris, that takes up time.
On top of that, gate agents’ “performance” is usually based on on-time pushback of flights (assuming there are not other external factors, of course). And, not surprisingly, corporate is watching them like a hawk – complete with company directives. So after a flight or two gets delayed while everyone on the flight was trying to figure out overhead bin space, they start to become, shall we say, hyper-aggressive about gate-checking bags.
How to avoid having to gate-check your carry-on
The only way to pretty much guarantee that you won’t be asked/forced to gate-check your bag is to have an earlier boarding group.
That means having the right credit card. Paying for the more expensive seat. Having status. You know the drill.
Be prepared!
But let’s say you’re not in the position to avoid gate-checking our bag. Say you bought Basic Economy with a debit card on Booking.com and are in Group 9. If nothing else, plan ahead, with the assumption that you’ll be told you have to gate check. Make sure all of the following are in your personal bag:
- Medication
- Your wallet and keys
- Your passport (if traveling internationally)
- Maybe ONE set of clothes, if possible, so you have something to change into if your “checked carry on” gets lost (it happens)
- Anything else you absolutely couldn’t do without if it was lost forever
And make sure you put an AirTag or something similar in that carry-on bag, just in case.
At the end of the day, this is one of those situations where the airline’s goals and the passenger’s goals don’t always align.
Passengers want to keep their bags with them. Airlines want to get the plane boarded, the door closed, and the flight pushed back on time.
Unfortunately, once gate agents start making decisions based on historical trends and boarding-time pressure, they’re often working with probabilities rather than what the overhead bins actually look like at that exact moment.
That means some flights will wind up with every bin completely full.
And others will wind up with passengers staring at half-empty overhead compartments while wondering why their bag is currently headed to baggage claim.
Is it annoying?
Absolutely.
Is it personal?
Probably not.
It’s usually just the airline trying to avoid a boarding process that turns into 150 people playing luggage Tetris at 35,000 feet.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
