I wasn’t even looking for these offers when they showed up.
Over the course of a couple of days, three emails from Barclays landed in my inbox. Each one was tied to a different card in my drawer, and each one was trying to do the same thing—get me to spend a little more.
On their own, they all seemed like the kind of easy promos that are hard to ignore. A few extra points here, a quick bonus there. Nothing complicated, nothing that required a ton of effort.
But seeing all three at the same time made me stop and take a closer look. And once I actually ran the numbers, it became pretty clear that they weren’t all worth doing.
In fact, I’m only planning to take advantage of one of them.
The Hawaiian Airlines Offer: The No-Brainer
The first offer, on my Hawaiian Airlines card, was the one that immediately stood out. It’s structured simply—earn an extra 10 miles per dollar on up to $250 in spend, for a maximum of 2,500 bonus miles. That’s not a huge number on paper, but the spending requirement is so low that it almost doesn’t matter. Even valuing those miles conservatively, you’re looking at around $40 in return on just $250 in purchases.
More importantly, it fits perfectly into what I’m already doing. I don’t have to move spending around or think about how to trigger it. It just happens. And that ties directly into why I decided to keep the Hawaiian Airlines credit card in the first place. This is exactly the kind of small, easy win that makes the card worth holding onto.
The Arrival+ Offer: Strong, But Competing
The second offer, on the Arrival+ card, took a little more digging to understand. At first glance, it advertises an extra 3 miles per dollar on all purchases, which sounds decent enough. But since the card already earns 2 miles per dollar, this is really a temporary boost to 5x on everyday spending.
That changes the math quite a bit. With Arrival miles worth about a cent each, you’re effectively getting a 5% return on up to $800 in spend, capped at 2,400 bonus miles. That’s actually a strong return, especially for purchases that wouldn’t normally fall into a bonus category.
If this were the only offer I had, I’d probably do it without thinking twice. But that’s not the situation. That $800 in spend has to come from somewhere, and right now I have other cards I’m prioritizing—whether that’s working toward a bonus, hitting a spending threshold, or just earning more in specific categories. So while the offer is objectively good, it’s still not enough to move it to the top of my list.
The JetBlue Offer: Not What I Need Right Now
Then there’s the JetBlue offer. This one is about as straightforward as it gets—earn 2,500 bonus points after making five purchases of $50 or more. That’s roughly $250 in spend for a return of $30 to $35, which is perfectly reasonable.
But this is where the decision has nothing to do with the math.
I already have a large balance of JetBlue points, and I’m not actively trying to build it up right now. Without a specific use in mind, earning more doesn’t really accomplish anything. It just adds to a pile that I’m not currently planning to spend.
So even though the return is fine, it doesn’t fit into what I’m trying to do.
Final Thought
Seeing all three offers come in at once was actually a good reminder of something I’ve been focusing on more this year. I’m not trying to maximize every opportunity anymore. Instead, I’m trying to be more intentional about which ones are actually worth the effort.
The Hawaiian offer makes sense because it’s easy and valuable without requiring any changes. The Arrival+ offer is good, but it competes with other priorities. And the JetBlue offer, while perfectly fine on paper, doesn’t align with my current goals at all.
Sometimes, the best move isn’t figuring out how to complete every offer that shows up in your inbox.
It’s recognizing which ones don’t fit—and being perfectly fine skipping them.
Want to comment on this post? Great! Read this first to help ensure it gets approved.
Want to sponsor a post, write something for Your Mileage May Vary, or put ads on our site? Click here for more info.
Like this post? Please share it! We have plenty more just like it and would love it if you decided to hang around and sign up to get emailed notifications of when we post.
Whether you’ve read our articles before or this is the first time you’re stopping by, we’re really glad you’re here and hope you come back to visit again!
This post first appeared on Your Mileage May Vary
